For the past week and a half, we’ve been making our way down the list of 11 statewide measures on next month’s ballot—trying to shed some light on issues from education funding to car insurance rates. Today – Proposition 36, which would amend California’s Three Strikes Law.

California has what is often called the toughest Three Strikes law in the country. It was passed in 1994. Under that law, anyone convicted of two serious or violent felonies can be sentenced to 25 years to life for a third felony–regardless of the nature of that third crime.

Proposition 36 would change that so that the third strike conviction would also have to be serious or violent to qualify for life behind bars. According to Stanford Law School Professor, Michael Romano, “It keeps intact the core purpose and intent of Three Strikes. But it would change the rules for people who have committed non-serious, non-violent crimes.”

In addition to being a professor, Romano is also director of Stanford Law School’s Three Strikes Project, a non-profit that provides legal help to defendants who’ve been sentenced to 25 years to life for a non-serious third strike: “folks who’ve been sentenced to life for shoplifting a pair of socks, stealing a dollar in change from a parked car, simple possession of 0.03 grams of methamphetamine.” Romano says these are exactly the kind of cases that would be affected by Prop 36 and that changing the Three Strikes law in this way would make the punishment fit the crime.

Under Prop 36, 2,800 felons currently serving 25-years-to-life for a non-serious third offense could appeal to reduce their sentences—a move the state legislative analyst says could save California $70 to $90 million dollars a year. And it would come at a time when the state prison system is struggling with overcrowding. However, these third strike inmates would only get those sentences reduced if they could convince a judge they’re no longer a threat to public safety.

But not everyone agrees. Mike Reynolds calls himself the father of California’s Three Strikes law. The idea was drafted in his backyard, and he’s been fighting for it ever since. He says since it went into effect, the Three Strikes law has played a big part in driving California’s crime rate down 50 percent. “What we have is an absolute track record of what it does and what it hasn’t done over the last 18 years,” said Reynolds. “And you would throw that away for some hollow promise that it might save $70 to 90 million?”

For Reynolds, this is about more than just numbers. It’s also about what happened to his family in 1992–two years before Three Strikes was passed. “I’m the father of an 18 year old girl named Kimber,” he said. “Kimber was murdered by two repeat offenders, fresh out of prison. It was over something as simple as a purse snatching. It was in a very good neighborhood, in front of one of the most popular restaurants in Fresno, in front of the patrons. One of the men pulled out a 357 Magnum, put it in my daughter’s ear, and assassinated her right on the spot.”

Reynolds says under Proposition 36, some serious felonies would be exempted from a potential third strike lifetime sentence—crimes like kidnapping, child abuse, and vehicular manslaughter. And he’s concerned that releasing some third strike offenders could lead to a spike in crime.

However, according to Mike Romano, the changes proposed in Prop 36 have been in effect for the past 12 years in both San Francisco and in L.A. County, where District Attorney Steve Cooley made the changes when he took office. “This is one of the rare opportunities where a law that the state is considering has actually been tried and tested in California,” he said. “It’s been tried and tested in Los Angeles County where crime is down more than throughout the rest of the state.”

But Prop 36 critic Mike Reynolds argues that L.A. is picking up the slack and keeping crime low with a large and growing police force, something the mayor’s made a top priority—even in tough economic times. He says many other communities don’t have the budget to do that.

Law enforcement comes down on both sides of the issue. Backers of Prop 36 include both the L-A and San Francisco District Attorneys, as well as LA Police Chief Charlie Beck. Opponents of Prop 36 include the California Police Chiefs Association, the State Sheriffs Association, and the District Attorneys Association, as well as the LA Police Protective League.

KCRW Radio App TuneIn Stitcher SoundCloud iTunes
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

14 Comments »

  • william myers said:

    I hope this passes,Its been wrong far too long!

  • California Elections: Voter Guide | Which Way L.A.? said:

    [...] coverage) Proposition 34 (Death penalty repeal) Proposition 35 (Human trafficking penalties) Proposition 36 (Three strikes law) Proposition 37 (Genetically engineered foods labeling) Proposition 38 (Tax to fund education and [...]

  • samantha s said:

    36 needs to pass my fiancee is in for life for 2 meth 1st strikes and a felony evasion for not reporting an address change that gave him life and hadn't used meth for 7 years when he got his third strike this is out of control for way too long now petty things

  • Gloria Estrada said:

    I know that prop.36 would help those who were convicted on a third for a non-violent crime, but what about those who were convicted for crimes like self-defense or protecting ones own life or spouse? What if the defense did not so his work when a deal was offered and let his client go to prison because his family could not give him more money so he just stopped working the case? Justice sometimes unkind for many reasons, and I hope that this prop.36 becomes law and that it will really look into cases that were unjustly trialed. Many people are in prison for wrong reasons and I hope that the state of Ca. will see this and give these people a chance. I want my son back, he was and is in prison this reason and sentenced to life!

    Gloria Estrada

  • San Diego Pool Builders said:

    Whoah this weblog is superb i love studying your articles. Remain up the wonderful operate! You realize, lots of individuals are hunting round for this info, you may enable them significantly.

  • emerging threats snort signatures said:

    It’s not that I want to copy your internet site, but I really like the pattern. Could you tell me which design are you using? Or was it tailor made?

  • grzybica paznokci pl said:

    Same słowa uznania należą się autorowi za tak ciekawie przedstawiony temat.

  • article source said:

    Thank you for another informative website. Where else could I get that type of info written in such a perfect way? I have a project that I’m just now working on, and I have been on the look out for such info.

  • Prime Credit Experts said:

    I have seen lots of useful issues on your web page about pc’s. However, I’ve the impression that notebook computers are still not quite powerful sufficiently to be a sensible choice if you frequently do things that require loads of power, just like video modifying. But for net surfing, statement processing, and majority of other prevalent computer work they are just fine, provided you never mind small screen size. Many thanks sharing your notions.

  • Thomas Stout said:

    They should just keep the old system. The law should have as many teeth as it needs to be an effective preventive measure against potential criminals.

  • Houston said:

    For personal injury cases, find an attorney who will work on your case on a contingency basis. This means he will not collect any fees from you unless you win the case.

  • pmp test prep said:

    "California has what is often called the toughest Three Strikes law in the country. It was passed in 1994. Under that law, anyone convicted of two serious or violent felonies can be sentenced to 25 years to life for a third felony–regardless of the nature of that third crime."

    - now i can also do the best for is then. i like it then.

  • Pool Builders said:

    Hey Nice Blog Article you know About Premier Pools & Spas as the best Pool Builders in the world is that they are the only pool building company to have international operations. Premier started its global expansion with their first international location in India.

  • Emerging EU said:

    In Eu it's not like this.

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.

BROUGHT TO YOU BY